It is right that HS2 2nd phase is cancelled. The project is grossly over budget, several years late, and only ever marginally justified by creative accounting to meet a political need.
Whether the cancellation was economically or politically motivated could be debated.
Some Tories find cancellation unattractive because they were complicit in its original approval and dislike the implicit criticism, but cancellation probably appeals to the Truss wing
That many in the north west are unhappy is no surprise Sunak may see wider benefits in funding smaller projects likely to deliver far quicker. Promising new stations, road upgrades, better buses etc etc in marginal constituencies could be a vote winner.
Politically it gives Labour a problem - will they assert "we will deal with it in office", endorse the policy (unlikely), announce they complete what has been started. Indecision can look like prevarication.
Sunak wants a new political play book. He is using issues which are emotive - immigration, EV delay to 2035, HS2, 20mph limits. It attempts to differentiates his premiership from both his predecessors and Labour. They are potential vote winners. He needs to take risks!
Starmer has thus far made Labour a largely policy free zone, The strategy (???) is traditional opposition - too early, too late, too little, too much, etc + "we are not the Tories" What emerges at the Labour party conference will be critical.
Many (on this forum) are adamant that EVs are the work of the devil, being tough on immigration is a vote winner even though some may find it morally repugnant, HS2 is a waste of money which fails to provide any benefit to those living remote from the route
Labour risk failing to communicate effectively that which they would do which opens them up to criticism at best and even ridicule. Why vote for them if they don't know what they would do differently.
Last edited by: Terry on Thu 5 Oct 23 at 01:52
|
HS2 costs out of control, says review new |
|
No FM2R |
|
5 Jan 20 14:03 |
|
HS2 costs out of control, says review new |
|
Bromptonaut |
|
5 Jan 20 15:04 |
|
HS2 costs out of control, says review new |
|
Zero |
|
5 Jan 20 16:11 |
|
HS2 costs out of control, says review new |
|
Bromptonaut |
|
5 Jan 20 16:22 |
|
HS2 costs out of control, says review new |
|
Rudedog |
|
5 Jan 20 17:17 |
|
HS2 costs out of control, says review new |
|
Zero |
|
5 Jan 20 17:36 |
|
HS2 costs out of control, says revie.. new |
|
Terry |
|
5 Jan 20 17:46 |
|
HS2 costs out of control, says revi.. new |
|
Bromptonaut |
|
5 Jan 20 18:13 |
|
HS2 costs out of control, says rev.. new |
|
Terry |
|
5 Jan 20 18:33 |
|
HS2 costs out of control, says re.. new |
|
Zero |
|
5 Jan 20 19:06 |
|
HS2 costs out of control, says re.. new |
|
Bromptonaut |
|
5 Jan 20 19:53 |
|
HS2 costs out of control, says r.. new |
|
No FM2R |
|
5 Jan 20 20:04 |
|
HS2 costs out of control, says revi.. new |
|
legacylad |
|
5 Jan 20 18:18 |
|
HS2 costs out of control, says rev.. new |
|
No FM2R |
|
5 Jan 20 18:30 |
|
HS2 costs out of control, says re.. new |
|
CGNorwich |
|
5 Jan 20 18:49 |
|
HS2 costs out of control, says r.. new |
|
Zero |
|
5 Jan 20 19:13 |
|
HS2 costs out of control, says rev.. new |
|
Zero |
|
5 Jan 20 19:15 |
|
HS2 costs out of control, says re.. new |
|
zippy |
|
5 Jan 20 20:41 |
|
HS2 costs out of control, says r.. new |
|
Zero |
|
5 Jan 20 21:20 |
|
HS2 costs out of control, says.. new |
|
No FM2R |
|
5 Jan 20 21:25 |
|
HS2 costs out of control, say.. new |
|
Terry |
|
5 Jan 20 21:46 |
|
HS2 costs out of control, sa.. new |
|
Zero |
|
5 Jan 20 22:35 |
|
HS2 costs out of control, says.. new |
|
zippy |
|
5 Jan 20 21:52 |
|
HS2 costs out of control, say.. new |
|
Zero |
|
5 Jan 20 22:34 |
|
HS2 costs out of control, sa.. new |
|
CGNorwich |
|
5 Jan 20 22:54 |
|
HS2 costs out of control, says r.. new |
|
Kevin |
|
5 Jan 20 23:00 |
|
HS2 costs out of control, says.. new |
|
Terry |
|
6 Jan 20 00:46 |
|
HS2 costs out of control, say.. new |
|
No FM2R |
|
6 Jan 20 01:47 |
|
HS2 costs out of control, sa.. new |
|
Lygonos |
|
6 Jan 20 09:53 |
|
HS2 costs out of control, s.. new |
|
smokie |
|
6 Jan 20 10:05 |
|
HS2 costs out of control, s.. new |
|
No FM2R |
|
6 Jan 20 10:06 |
|
HS2 costs out of control, say.. new |
|
Bromptonaut |
|
6 Jan 20 10:40 |
|
HS2 costs out of control, sa.. new |
|
Zero |
|
6 Jan 20 10:51 |
|
HS2 costs out of control, s.. new |
|
Netsur |
|
6 Jan 20 16:41 |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
HS2 costs out of control, says review new |
|
No FM2R |
|
6 Jan 20 17:07 |
|
HS2 costs out of control, says review new |
|
Bromptonaut |
|
6 Jan 20 17:30 |
|
HS2 costs out of control, says review new |
|
No FM2R |
|
6 Jan 20 17:39 |
|
HS2 costs out of control, says review new |
|
tyrednemotional |
|
7 Jan 20 07:17 |
|
HS2 costs out of control, says revie.. new |
|
Manatee |
|
7 Jan 20 10:18 |
|
HS2 costs out of control, says revi.. new |
|
No FM2R |
|
7 Jan 20 11:00 |
|
HS2 costs out of control, says rev.. new |
|
No FM2R |
|
7 Jan 20 11:02 |
|
HS2 costs out of control, says re.. new |
|
No FM2R |
|
7 Jan 20 11:37 |
|
HS2 costs out of control, says r.. new |
|
zippy |
|
7 Jan 20 14:53 |
|
HS2 costs out of control, says revi.. new |
|
tyrednemotional |
|
7 Jan 20 17:26 |
|
HS2 costs out of control, says rev.. new |
|
Crankcase |
|
7 Jan 20 17:52 |
|
HS2 costs out of control, says re.. new |
|
Zero |
|
7 Jan 20 17:56 |
|
HS2 costs out of control, says r.. new |
|
Crankcase |
|
7 Jan 20 18:00 |
|
HS2 costs out of control, says.. new |
|
Zero |
|
7 Jan 20 18:24 |
|
HS2 costs out of control, say.. new |
|
Zero |
|
7 Jan 20 18:26 |
|
HS2 costs out of control, say.. new |
|
Crankcase |
|
7 Jan 20 18:34 |
|
HS2 costs out of control, sa.. new |
|
Zero |
|
7 Jan 20 19:00 |
|
HS2 costs out of control, says re.. new |
|
tyrednemotional |
|
7 Jan 20 18:22 |
|
HS2 costs out of control, says r.. new |
|
No FM2R |
|
7 Jan 20 18:57 |
|
HS2 costs out of control, says.. new |
|
tyrednemotional |
|
7 Jan 20 21:41 |
|
HS2 costs out of control, say.. new |
|
No FM2R |
|
7 Jan 20 21:45 |
|
HS2 costs out of control, says rev.. new |
|
Manatee |
|
8 Jan 20 10:11 |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
HS2 costs out of control, says review new |
|
sooty123 |
|
11 Feb 20 08:38 |
|
HS2 costs out of control, says review new |
|
Lygonos |
|
11 Feb 20 10:11 |
|
HS2 costs out of control, says review new |
|
Zero |
|
11 Feb 20 10:18 |
|
HS2 costs out of control, says review new |
|
PeterS |
|
11 Feb 20 10:47 |
|
HS2 costs out of control, says review new |
|
Robin O'Reliant |
|
11 Feb 20 10:59 |
|
HS2 costs out of control, says review new |
|
Manatee |
|
11 Feb 20 11:52 |
|
HS2 costs out of control, says review new |
|
Bromptonaut |
|
11 Feb 20 16:48 |
|
HS2 costs out of control, says review new |
|
Bromptonaut |
|
11 Feb 20 18:29 |
|
HS2 costs out of control, says revie.. new |
|
Terry |
|
11 Feb 20 23:32 |
|
HS2 costs out of control, says revi.. new |
|
zippy |
|
12 Feb 20 01:33 |
|
HS2 costs out of control, says rev.. new |
|
Terry |
|
12 Feb 20 09:23 |
|
HS2 costs out of control, says rev.. new |
|
sooty123 |
|
12 Feb 20 10:54 |
|
HS2 costs out of control, says re.. new |
|
zippy |
|
12 Feb 20 11:25 |
|
HS2 costs out of control, says revi.. new |
|
sooty123 |
|
12 Feb 20 10:49 |
|
HS2 costs out of control, says rev.. new |
|
Bromptonaut |
|
12 Feb 20 11:13 |
|
HS2 costs out of control, says review new |
|
Manatee |
|
12 Feb 20 10:34 |
|
HS2 costs out of control, says revie.. new |
|
sooty123 |
|
12 Feb 20 11:21 |
|
HS2 costs out of control, says revi.. new |
|
Terry |
|
12 Feb 20 15:57 |
|
HS2 costs out of control, says rev.. new |
|
No FM2R |
|
12 Feb 20 16:09 |
|
HS2 costs out of control, says re.. new |
|
CGNorwich |
|
12 Feb 20 16:49 |
|
HS2 costs out of control, says r.. new |
|
sooty123 |
|
12 Feb 20 16:54 |
|
HS2 costs out of control, says r.. new |
|
No FM2R |
|
12 Feb 20 16:57 |
|
HS3 up for the chop? new |
|
sooty123 |
|
15 Nov 21 11:00 |
|
HS3 up for the chop? new |
|
sooty123 |
|
15 Nov 21 20:53 |
|
HS3 up for the chop? new |
|
Bromptonaut |
|
16 Nov 21 10:33 |
|
HS3 up for the chop? new |
|
sooty123 |
|
16 Nov 21 13:21 |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
HS3 up for the chop? new |
|
bathtub tom |
|
16 Nov 21 16:03 |
|
HS3 up for the chop? new |
|
Clk Sec |
|
16 Nov 21 17:07 |
|
HS3 up for the chop? new |
|
sooty123 |
|
18 Nov 21 07:43 |
|
HS3 up for the chop? new |
|
Terry |
|
18 Nov 21 10:43 |
|
HS3 up for the chop? new |
|
Zero |
|
18 Nov 21 10:58 |
|
HS3 up for the chop? new |
|
No FM2R |
|
18 Nov 21 11:09 |
|
HS3 up for the chop? new |
|
Zero |
|
18 Nov 21 20:23 |
|
HS3 up for the chop? new |
|
No FM2R |
|
18 Nov 21 11:11 |
|
HS3 up for the chop? new |
|
sooty123 |
|
18 Nov 21 12:10 |
|
HS3 up for the chop? new |
|
Manatee |
|
18 Nov 21 12:24 |
|
HS3 up for the chop? new |
|
sooty123 |
|
18 Nov 21 22:13 |
|
HS3 up for the chop? new |
|
Terry |
|
19 Nov 21 02:33 |
|
HS3 up for the chop? new |
|
No FM2R |
|
19 Nov 21 04:02 |
|
HS3 up for the chop? new |
|
sooty123 |
|
19 Nov 21 07:50 |
|
HS3 up for the chop? new |
|
Zero |
|
20 Nov 21 11:49 |
|
HS3 up for the chop? new |
|
Bromptonaut |
|
20 Nov 21 15:11 |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
more delays new |
|
sooty123 |
|
27 Jan 23 09:23 |
|
more delays new |
|
tyrednemotional |
|
27 Jan 23 09:29 |
|
more delays new |
|
Bromptonaut |
|
27 Jan 23 09:41 |
|
more delays new |
|
Bromptonaut |
|
27 Jan 23 09:53 |
|
more delays new |
|
tyrednemotional |
|
27 Jan 23 09:59 |
|
more delays new |
|
Terry |
|
27 Jan 23 10:50 |
|
more delays new |
|
Manatee |
|
27 Jan 23 10:55 |
|
more delays new |
|
Bromptonaut |
|
27 Jan 23 13:34 |
|
more delays new |
|
henry k |
|
10 Mar 23 14:00 |
|
more delays new |
|
sooty123 |
|
9 Mar 23 19:28 |
|
more delays new |
|
Kevin |
|
9 Mar 23 19:56 |
|
more delays new |
|
Zero |
|
9 Mar 23 21:40 |
|
more delays new |
|
tyrednemotional |
|
9 Mar 23 22:07 |
|
more delays new |
|
legacylad |
|
9 Mar 23 22:25 |
|
more delays new |
|
tyrednemotional |
|
9 Mar 23 22:30 |
|
more delays new |
|
legacylad |
|
9 Mar 23 22:35 |
|
more delays new |
|
Kevin |
|
9 Mar 23 22:31 |
|
more delays new |
|
tyrednemotional |
|
9 Mar 23 22:35 |
|
more delays new |
|
Terry |
|
10 Mar 23 00:28 |
|
more delays new |
|
tyrednemotional |
|
10 Mar 23 09:21 |
|
more delays new |
|
sooty123 |
|
14 Sep 23 15:33 |
|
more delays new |
|
tyrednemotional |
|
14 Sep 23 16:16 |
|
more delays new |
|
Terry |
|
14 Sep 23 19:39 |
|
more delays new |
|
Ted |
|
14 Sep 23 22:19 |
|
more delays new |
|
Bromptonaut |
|
15 Sep 23 09:40 |
|
more delays new |
|
Terry |
|
15 Sep 23 10:32 |
|
more delays new |
|
Bromptonaut |
|
16 Sep 23 10:17 |
|
more delays new |
|
Terry |
|
16 Sep 23 14:10 |
|
more delays new |
|
sooty123 |
|
15 Sep 23 11:23 |
|
cancellation on the way? new |
|
sooty123 |
|
24 Sep 23 10:09 |
|
cancellation on the way? new |
|
Bromptonaut |
|
24 Sep 23 10:36 |
|
cancellation on the way? new |
|
Terry |
|
24 Sep 23 10:48 |
|
cancellation on the way? new |
|
Duncan |
|
24 Sep 23 10:55 |
|
cancellation on the way? new |
|
Biggles |
|
24 Sep 23 12:50 |
|
cancellation on the way? new |
|
Bromptonaut |
|
24 Sep 23 16:54 |
|
cancellation on the way? new |
|
sooty123 |
|
24 Sep 23 10:48 |
|
cancellation on the way? new |
|
Duncan |
|
24 Sep 23 10:57 |
|
cancellation on the way? new |
|
CGNorwich |
|
24 Sep 23 11:10 |
|
cancellation on the way? new |
|
Runfer D'Hills |
|
24 Sep 23 11:24 |
|
cancellation on the way? new |
|
Biggles |
|
24 Sep 23 12:52 |
|
cancellation on the way? new |
|
Bromptonaut |
|
24 Sep 23 12:58 |
|
cancellation on the way? new |
|
Terry |
|
24 Sep 23 14:45 |
|
cancellation on the way? new |
|
Bromptonaut |
|
24 Sep 23 16:32 |
|
cancellation on the way? new |
|
CGNorwich |
|
24 Sep 23 21:10 |
|
cancellation on the way? new |
|
Duncan |
|
24 Sep 23 14:59 |
|
cancellation on the way? new |
|
Runfer D'Hills |
|
24 Sep 23 15:42 |
|
HS2 costs out of control, says review new |
|
Bromptonaut |
|
28 Sep 23 14:59 |
|
HS2 costs out of control, says review new |
|
sooty123 |
|
4 Oct 23 19:17 |
|
HS2 costs out of control, says review new |
|
Manatee |
|
4 Oct 23 20:07 |
|
HS2 costs out of control, says review new |
|
sooty123 |
|
4 Oct 23 20:14 |
|
HS2 costs out of control, says review new |
|
Manatee |
|
4 Oct 23 20:39 |
|
HS2 costs out of control, says revie.. new |
|
sooty123 |
|
4 Oct 23 21:08 |
|
HS2 costs out of control, says revi.. new |
|
smokie |
|
4 Oct 23 22:01 |
|
HS2 costs out of control, says rev.. new |
|
tyrednemotional |
|
4 Oct 23 22:24 |
|
HS2 costs out of control, says rev.. new |
|
Manatee |
|
4 Oct 23 22:38 |
|
HS2 costs out of control, says revi.. new |
|
Manatee |
|
4 Oct 23 22:01 |
|
HS2 costs out of control, says .. new |
|
Terry |
|
5 Oct 23 01:48 |
|
HS2 costs out of control, says re.. new |
|
sooty123 |
|
5 Oct 23 06:50 |
|
HS2 costs out of control, says r.. new |
|
Bobby |
|
5 Oct 23 07:46 |
|
HS2 costs out of control, says re.. new |
|
Manatee |
|
5 Oct 23 08:56 |
|
HS2 costs out of control, says r.. new |
|
smokie |
|
5 Oct 23 10:25 |
|
HS2 costs out of control, says r.. new |
|
Terry |
|
5 Oct 23 10:32 |
|
HS2 costs out of control, says.. new |
|
CGNorwich |
|
5 Oct 23 10:52 |
|
HS2 costs out of control, says r.. new |
|
Manatee |
|
5 Oct 23 11:38 |
|
HS2 costs out of control, says.. new |
|
Manatee |
|
5 Oct 23 14:54 |
|
HS2 costs out of control, says.. new |
|
Terry |
|
5 Oct 23 16:27 |
|
HS2 costs out of control, say.. new |
|
sooty123 |
|
5 Oct 23 19:41 |
|
HS2 costs out of control, sa.. new |
|
smokie |
|
5 Oct 23 20:11 |
|
HS2 costs out of control, s.. new |
|
Terry |
|
6 Oct 23 11:16 |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
HS2 costs out of control, says review new |
|
Kevin |
|
6 Oct 23 13:08 |
|
HS2 costs out of control, says review new |
|
Terry |
|
6 Oct 23 15:59 |
|
HS2 costs out of control, says review new |
|
Manatee |
|
6 Oct 23 18:15 |
|
HS2 costs out of control, says review new |
|
Terry |
|
6 Oct 23 19:27 |
|
HS2 costs out of control, says review new |
|
Kevin |
|
6 Oct 23 19:28 |
|
HS2 costs out of control, says revie.. new |
|
Manatee |
|
6 Oct 23 20:20 |
|
HS2 costs out of control, says revi.. new |
|
sooty123 |
|
6 Oct 23 20:55 |
|
HS2 costs out of control, says rev.. new |
|
Bromptonaut |
|
6 Oct 23 22:39 |
|
HS2 costs out of control, says re.. new |
|
sooty123 |
|
6 Oct 23 23:03 |
|
HS2 costs out of control, says r.. new |
|
sooty123 |
|
6 Oct 23 23:11 |
|
HS2 costs out of control, says re.. new |
|
smokie |
|
7 Oct 23 00:05 |
|
HS2 costs out of control, says r.. new |
|
tyrednemotional |
|
7 Oct 23 09:02 |
|
HS2 costs out of control, says.. new |
|
Bromptonaut |
|
7 Oct 23 10:24 |
|
HS2 costs out of control, says rev.. new |
|
Manatee |
|
7 Oct 23 11:08 |
|
HS2 costs out of control, says re.. new |
|
Manatee |
|
7 Oct 23 11:12 |
|
HS2 costs out of control, says r.. new |
|
Manatee |
|
7 Oct 23 11:19 |
|
HS2 costs out of control, says.. new |
|
sooty123 |
|
7 Oct 23 11:41 |
|
HS2 costs out of control, say.. new |
|
Bromptonaut |
|
7 Oct 23 11:49 |
|
HS2 costs out of control, sa.. new |
|
sooty123 |
|
7 Oct 23 15:58 |
|
HS2 costs out of control, s.. new |
|
tyrednemotional |
|
7 Oct 23 16:25 |
|
HS2 costs out of control, says r.. new |
|
Terry |
|
7 Oct 23 15:10 |
|
HS2 costs out of control, says.. new |
|
Manatee |
|
7 Oct 23 18:39 |
|
HS2 costs out of control, say.. new |
|
Terry |
|
7 Oct 23 19:02 |
|
HS2 costs out of control, sa.. new |
|
Manatee |
|
7 Oct 23 20:16 |
|
HS2 costs out of control, say.. new |
|
Bobby |
|
7 Oct 23 19:03 |
|
HS2 costs out of control, sa.. new |
|
Bromptonaut |
|
7 Oct 23 20:41 |
|
HS2 costs out of control, s.. new |
|
tyrednemotional |
|
7 Oct 23 20:50 |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
HS2 costs out of control, says review new |
|
Bromptonaut |
|
7 Oct 23 20:54 |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|