Motoring Discussion > Do enthusiasts know better? Miscellaneous
Thread Author: Rudedog Replies: 60

 Do enthusiasts know better? - Harleyman

>>
>> Nahhh, any old 20W/50 slop will do in the old 'uns.

Non-detergent SAE 50 in the 45 (and all other old Harleys) unless you fancy rebuilding the bottom end. Roller bearing engine, see, relies on volume rather than pressure. That's one reason why I distrust Haynes' books of lies, they recommend Castrol 20/50 for Ironhead Sportsters; I followed their advice and it cost me a crank. Stuck to straight 50 ever since and never had any more problems.

To an extent you are right, but I did say you shouldn't move TOO far from the manufacturer's spec. And if you're going to hammer the motor on a regular basis, stands to reason you put the right stuff in.
 Messages Author Date
 Do enthusiasts know better?  Rudedog 30 Dec 12 22:08
 Do enthusiasts know better?  Harleyman 31 Dec 12 00:01
 Do enthusiasts know better?  Dave_ 31 Dec 12 00:11
 Do enthusiasts know better?  Harleyman 31 Dec 12 00:28
 Do enthusiasts know better?  Rudedog 31 Dec 12 00:59
 Do enthusiasts know better?  Tigger 31 Dec 12 06:32
 Do enthusiasts know better?  Old Navy 31 Dec 12 08:57
 Do enthusiasts know better?  Slidingpillar 31 Dec 12 09:35
 Do enthusiasts know better?  Tigger 31 Dec 12 11:09
 Do enthusiasts know better?  Zero 31 Dec 12 11:41
 Do enthusiasts know better?  madf 31 Dec 12 12:05
 Do enthusiasts know better?  - 31 Dec 12 12:14
 Do enthusiasts know better?  Rudedog 31 Dec 12 13:00
 Do enthusiasts know better?  .... 31 Dec 12 13:06
  
 Do enthusiasts know better?  sooty123 31 Dec 12 13:21
 Do enthusiasts know better?  NortonES2 31 Dec 12 13:57
 Do enthusiasts know better?  .... 31 Dec 12 14:04
 Do enthusiasts know better?  - 31 Dec 12 14:21
 Do enthusiasts know better?  Zero 31 Dec 12 14:27
 Do enthusiasts know better?  NortonES2 31 Dec 12 14:22
 Do enthusiasts know better?  Rudedog 31 Dec 12 14:49
  
 Do enthusiasts know better?  henry k 31 Dec 12 13:18
 Do enthusiasts know better?  Shiny 31 Dec 12 15:17
 Do enthusiasts know better?  Zero 31 Dec 12 15:33
 Do enthusiasts know better?  Lygonos 31 Dec 12 16:01
 Do enthusiasts know better?  madf 31 Dec 12 16:22
 Do enthusiasts know better?  madf 31 Dec 12 16:21
 Do enthusiasts know better?  Lygonos 31 Dec 12 16:30
 Do enthusiasts know better?  Runfer D'Hills 31 Dec 12 16:47
 Do enthusiasts know better?  Lygonos 31 Dec 12 16:52
 Do enthusiasts know better?  Cliff Pope 31 Dec 12 17:16
 Do enthusiasts know better?  Zero 31 Dec 12 17:18
 Do enthusiasts know better?  Lygonos 31 Dec 12 17:21
 Do enthusiasts know better?  Cliff Pope 1 Jan 13 16:10
  
 Do enthusiasts know better?  Zero 1 Jan 13 17:21
  
 Do enthusiasts know better?  corax 31 Dec 12 17:32
 Do enthusiasts know better?  Gromit 31 Dec 12 22:46
 Do enthusiasts know better?  Tigger 1 Jan 13 07:38
 Do enthusiasts know better?  Old Navy 1 Jan 13 08:41
 Do enthusiasts know better?  - 1 Jan 13 10:00
  
 Do enthusiasts know better?  Runfer D'Hills 1 Jan 13 10:39
 Do enthusiasts know better?  Zero 1 Jan 13 10:47
 Do enthusiasts know better?  Runfer D'Hills 1 Jan 13 11:24
 Do enthusiasts know better?  .... 1 Jan 13 14:19
 Do enthusiasts know better?  Gromit 1 Jan 13 17:23
 Do enthusiasts know better?  Runfer D'Hills 1 Jan 13 17:49
 Do enthusiasts know better?  Gromit 2 Jan 13 10:53
 Do enthusiasts know better?  Auntie Lockbrakes 6 Jan 13 19:49
 Do enthusiasts know better?  Tigger 2 Jan 13 11:02
 Do enthusiasts know better?  - 2 Jan 13 11:44
 Do enthusiasts know better?  Tigger 2 Jan 13 13:09
 Do enthusiasts know better?  - 2 Jan 13 13:31
 Do enthusiasts know better?  Tigger 2 Jan 13 13:34
 Do enthusiasts know better?  Tigger 8 Jan 13 15:07
 Do enthusiasts know better?  - 8 Jan 13 19:51
 Do enthusiasts know better?  Zero 8 Jan 13 19:56
 Do enthusiasts know better?  - 8 Jan 13 20:06
 Do enthusiasts know better?  Zero 8 Jan 13 20:29
  
 Do enthusiasts know better?  Tigger 6 Jan 13 09:05
 Do enthusiasts know better?  No FM2R 2 Jan 13 14:11
 Do enthusiasts know better?  Dutchie 8 Jan 13 20:21
Latest Forum Posts