>> Its a nice looking car loaded with toys, but no way would I lash out
>> over 25 grand for one. Its just not special enough at that money.
>>
That's the million pound question though - what is?
I test drove the Ford Mondeo, Audi A5, Citroen C5 and DS5, Honda Accord, Skoda Superb, VW CC, Seat Leon, and the Kia Optimia. I tried to test drive a Jag but wasn't allowed to by the dealer*; don't want another BMW, and can't bear to be inside a Merc (I dunno whether it's the smell, the bland design, or the fact that anything clever is a "something-tronic".)
So, to synopsisize you:
The Ford:
I don't understand why people rave about the Mondeo. I thought it was fairly cheaply made, the gearbox was terrible, and you didn't get much for your money. Interestingly, the only diesels I see belching smoke nowadays are three year old Mondeos, which doesn't inspire confidence.
The Audi:
A5 is a very nice car, brother had one and drove it all over Europe. Liked the little colour screen on the dash and the power from the twin-turbo diesel. Didn't like the dated sat nav and ride quality. Considered A4, not a cheap car, didn't want to be tarnished as an Audi driver.
Citroen C5 and DS5:
Both nice cars - just not what they could be. The DS5 had some really innovative features (HUD etc) and some mind-bogglingly stupid decisions. Which to be fair, is very Citroen. Fuel economy was pretty shocking on a longer run.
The C5 is a cracking car, let down by a terrible automatic gearbox. Ride is superb, lots of toys, comfortable seats, decent prices - but, that gearbox! When pulling away it's a bit like using the telegraph on a cruise liner's bridge to signal to the engine room for "SLOW AHEAD". Any slow maneuvers are actually performed in a series of abrupt lurches and moments of panic as the car rockets unexpectedly towards walls, other cars, pedestrians, lamp posts etc.
The Honda:
Can't put my finger on it, was just boring. And expensive.
Skoda Superb:
My dad has one of these which gave me the opportunity to get some fairly long drives in it. Nice car, excellent DSG gearbox, and good fuel economy. He's had it chipped to 205bhp. Crap sat nav. No DAB. It's almost as much as a Passat but has two-year-old technology fished out of the VAG parts bin. Close contender.
Passat CC (or just the CC as it's called now):
Very nice car. Brother has one (again, so extended test drive, albeit in the Czech Republic). Can't fault it really. Tiny bit boring inside, otherwise, an excellent car. However, to load it up with the same spec as the Insignia would have taken the asking price to over £35k.
Seat Leon:
It's like a Golf, but with the same comments as for the Skoda. There's a new one coming out next year but the local dealer was so useless I gave up. And it's made in Spain.
The Kia:
Now, this was a toughie. It's a really nice car. I'm not brand snobbish (as you'll no doubt have guessed from the Vauxhall) but it's hamstrung by the dinky little 1.7 diesel under the bonnet. It takes an age to get to 60 and you have to change down to overtake on the motorway.
Which brings us back to the Insignia. I think they're great looking cars; it's loaded with technology (I only do my job because I like pushing buttons), fuel economy is great (it even shows you a graph of how you're doing - secretly, I'm James May), the "lifetime" warranty is tempting and it's actually quite inspiring to drive.
At the same time, it can plod safely home up the motorway in comfort while I drift off to Radio 4. The dealer was friendly and let me take it for an unaccompanied test drive. I handed my BMW to their service department to MOT, which was quick, efficient, and cost £35.
It's hard to describe. A lot of thought has gone into the Insignia - it's nothing like the Vectra of old. Even the fonts on the dashboard are nice. I wish it had keyless entry and the rear visibility is crap, but these are niggles. Oh, and it's made in the UK.
* I've just emailed a copy of the invoice for the Insignia to Jaguar Land-Rover's head office. Though now they're shifting productions to China I wouldn't buy one anyway.
Last edited by: Fursty Ferret on Tue 20 Nov 12 at 10:17
|