Motoring Discussion > Bottom end failure Car Deals
Thread Author: smokie Replies: 30

 Bottom end failure - John H
>> Please can we keep this simple and to the point please.
>>

It is clear that a lot of the respondents to this thread do not have the benefit of having read smokie's original, now hidden, post on this subject. Otherwise many of the questions and false assumptions could have been avoided.

I think it is very unlikely that a missed oil service should lead to a bottom end failure. BTW, has the bearing failed or the conrod bottom end? A possible manufacturing defect which just happens to fail soon after a belated service or, as Lygonos hints, someone may have started the engine without oil circulating. How that may have happened is anybody's guess. Smokie should get the engine parts examined by an independent professional Mechanical Engineer and or a Metallurgist.
Warranty is irrelevant. take action in the small claims court as per the examples of the Corsa camshaft failures people on HJ's website.
Last edited by: John H on Thu 29 Apr 10 at 19:49
 Messages Author Date
 Bottom end failure  smokie 29 Apr 10 09:13
 Bottom end failure  Stuu 29 Apr 10 09:21
 Bottom end failure  Fenlander 29 Apr 10 09:29
 Bottom end failure  Iffy 29 Apr 10 09:34
 Bottom end failure  RichardW 29 Apr 10 09:32
 Bottom end failure  teabelly 29 Apr 10 09:32
 Bottom end failure  Zero 29 Apr 10 09:43
 Bottom end failure  Number_Cruncher 29 Apr 10 10:12
 Bottom end failure  FotheringtonTomas 29 Apr 10 10:27
 Bottom end failure  Bigtee 29 Apr 10 10:37
 Bottom end failure  madf 29 Apr 10 13:33
 Bottom end failure  Lygonos 29 Apr 10 14:09
 Bottom end failure  hawkeye 29 Apr 10 18:37
 Bottom end failure  Bellboy 29 Apr 10 19:11
 Bottom end failure  John H 29 Apr 10 19:48
 Bottom end failure  Bellboy 29 Apr 10 20:15
 Bottom end failure  Fenlander 30 Apr 10 00:09
 Bottom end failure  rtj70 30 Apr 10 00:27
 Bottom end failure  RattleandSmoke 30 Apr 10 00:33
 Bottom end failure  Hard Cheese 30 Apr 10 07:59
 Bottom end failure  John H 30 Apr 10 10:14
 Bottom end failure  FotheringtonTomas 30 Apr 10 09:43
 Bottom end failure  R.P. 30 Apr 10 09:51
 Bottom end failure  car4play 30 Apr 10 09:54
 Bottom end failure  John H 30 Apr 10 10:03
 Bottom end failure  FotheringtonTomas 30 Apr 10 10:02
 Bottom end failure  R.P. 30 Apr 10 10:06
 Bottom end failure  John H 30 Apr 10 10:09
 Bottom end failure  R.P. 30 Apr 10 10:10
 Bottom end failure  Hard Cheese 30 Apr 10 10:19
 Bottom end failure  smokie 30 Apr 10 11:11
Latest Forum Posts