Non-motoring > Naming and shaming Legal Questions
Thread Author: Fursty Ferret Replies: 50

 Naming and shaming - Iffy
The key point legally is right of reply.

Ideally, the organisation should be approached for a comment.

The problem with that on a site such as this is who's going to do it?

If the organisation approaches the site to make a comment, it should be carried with the same prominence.

The criticism made needs to be fair and reasonable.

There is a danger with an anonymous forum that someone could post something out of malice - hence the desirability of getting a comment from the other side, which would weed out false posts.

It is possible for the forum to make a judgment.

For example, I've been on here and the other place for a while now and everyone knows I live in the north and have a CC3.

So if I post with a reasonable sounding whinge about a Ford dealer in my part of the world, it will ring true.

A similar post from a new member is more of a challenge.




 Messages Author Date
 Naming and shaming  Fursty Ferret 31 Mar 10 11:39
 Naming and shaming  FotheringtonTomas 31 Mar 10 12:07
 Naming and shaming  R.P. 31 Mar 10 12:21
 Naming and shaming  BobbyG 31 Mar 10 12:26
 Naming and shaming  R.P. 31 Mar 10 12:56
 Naming and shaming  FotheringtonTomas 31 Mar 10 13:19
 Naming and shaming  movilogo 31 Mar 10 13:49
 Naming and shaming  - 31 Mar 10 14:07
 Naming and shaming  Fenlander 31 Mar 10 14:23
 Naming and shaming  RattleandSmoke 31 Mar 10 14:46
 Naming and shaming  Stuu 31 Mar 10 15:14
 Naming and shaming  movilogo 31 Mar 10 15:42
 Naming and shaming  Bigtee 31 Mar 10 15:59
 Naming and shaming  Iffy 31 Mar 10 18:48
  
 Naming and shaming  R.P. 31 Mar 10 18:53
 Naming and shaming  FotheringtonTomas 31 Mar 10 20:38
 Naming and shaming  Iffy 31 Mar 10 20:52
 Naming and shaming  FotheringtonTomas 31 Mar 10 20:58
 Naming and shaming  Iffy 31 Mar 10 21:16
 Naming and shaming  Armel Coussine 31 Mar 10 21:52
 Naming and shaming  Zero 31 Mar 10 22:16
 Naming and shaming  Fullchat 31 Mar 10 22:24
 Naming and shaming  Armel Coussine 31 Mar 10 22:53
 Naming and shaming  FotheringtonTomas 31 Mar 10 23:17
 Naming and shaming  FotheringtonTomas 31 Mar 10 23:13
 Naming and shaming  R.P. 31 Mar 10 23:15
 Naming and shaming  FotheringtonTomas 31 Mar 10 23:20
 Naming and shaming  FotheringtonTomas 31 Mar 10 23:37
  
 Naming and shaming  Armel Coussine 31 Mar 10 23:21
 Naming and shaming  bathtub tom 1 Apr 10 00:43
 Naming and shaming  Pat 1 Apr 10 06:12
 Naming and shaming  smokie 1 Apr 10 07:33
 Naming and shaming  Iffy 1 Apr 10 07:44
 Naming and shaming  BobbyG 1 Apr 10 08:41
 Naming and shaming  Fenlander 1 Apr 10 09:11
 Naming and shaming  Mapmaker 1 Apr 10 10:28
  
 Naming and shaming  Iffy 1 Apr 10 10:38
  
 Naming and shaming  FotheringtonTomas 1 Apr 10 10:52
 Naming and shaming  Statistical Outlier 1 Apr 10 10:55
 Naming and shaming  Crankcase 1 Apr 10 10:56
 Naming and shaming  Focusless 1 Apr 10 10:57
 Naming and shaming  Statistical Outlier 1 Apr 10 11:01
 Naming and shaming  Focusless 1 Apr 10 11:04
 Naming and shaming  Mapmaker 1 Apr 10 12:25
 Naming and shaming  car4play 1 Apr 10 12:38
 Naming and shaming  FotheringtonTomas 1 Apr 10 13:20
 Car4play name and shame policy  FotheringtonTomas 1 Apr 10 13:17
 Car4play name and shame policy  Iffy 2 Apr 10 08:40
 Car4play name and shame policy  car4play 2 Apr 10 12:01
 Car4play name and shame policy  Iffy 2 Apr 10 13:44
 Naming and shaming  L'escargot 2 Apr 10 13:24
Latest Forum Posts