Motoring Discussion > Forth Road Bridge closed for a couple of days Miscellaneous
Thread Author: Bobby Replies: 40

 Forth Road Bridge closed for a couple of days - Bobby
trafficscotland.org/news/story.aspx?id=13212

One side has been closed for last couple of days as they discovered a problem with some steel beams. Now closing both sides for next 24 hours initially.

Of all the fly on the wall real-life tv program docu type things, I would love to see what the team do to resolve this. According to one report this morning, they had a team of engineers working throughout the night on calculations of load bearings and structures to try and come up with a solution.

 Forth Road Bridge closed for a couple of days - Bobby
Update, going to be closed to the New Year!
Nightmare!!
 Forth Road Bridge closed for a couple of days - zippy
Lucky that they found out before something happened.

Wasn't the new Severn bridge built because someone worked out that the old one would be at risk of failure in the event of a traffic jam of HGVs or is it an "old wives tale"?
 Forth Road Bridge closed for a couple of days - Harleyman
>> Lucky that they found out before something happened.
>>
>> Wasn't the new Severn bridge built because someone worked out that the old one would
>> be at risk of failure in the event of a traffic jam of HGVs or
>> is it an "old wives tale"?
>>

More likely it was built because the tailbacks on the old one were becoming ridiculous.

Out of interest; has the Forth railway bridge ever been closed due to structural problems or faults?
 Forth Road Bridge closed for a couple of days - Lygonos
>>has the Forth railway bridge ever been closed due to structural problems or faults

To my knowledge the Forth Bridge has never been closed due to these issues - while it's metalwork was being heavily renovated (old paint slag-blasted and painted with a 3-layer epoxy finish) after 2002 it may have had brief closures to facilitate renovations and in the 90s when the rails were replaced.

Apparently its service life is currently estimated to be "over 100 years". I expect it was massively over-engineered after the failure of the Tay Bridge.

It really is an impressive piece of kit!


en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Forth_Bridge#World_Heritage_Site_status
Last edited by: Lygonos on Fri 4 Dec 15 at 14:34
 Forth Road Bridge closed for a couple of days - Runfer D'Hills
This makes me feel quite old. I can just about remember as a pre-school child crossing the Forth on the car ferry in my dad's Zephyr before the road bridge was built ( or completed anyway )

There's an embarrassing photo somewhere with me on that ferry aged about 3 or so in a Frank Spencer type beige mac and a black beret. I must get around to destroying that.
 Forth Road Bridge closed for a couple of days - martin aston
Snap. Not only remember the ferry but going several times to sit in the car at a vantage point and watch the bridge being built. I recall there was what we would now call an urban legend that a drunk sailor walked the length of the cables from one side to the other before the road deck was laid.
 Forth Road Bridge closed for a couple of days - Runfer D'Hills
Edinburgh childhood Martin?

Later, long after it was built and we were older, I can remember cycling down to the bridge and over it on the combined footpath/cycle way. We sometimes stopped halfway and climbed over the handrail to dangle in mid air off the bridge for a dare or possibly even more stupidly, sort of tightrope walk the handrail. Fall to one side onto the path, fall to the other and there would have been an eventual splash.

Makes me shiver now but at the time and in the mindset of an idiotic 12 year old it seemed like a good idea...
 Forth Road Bridge closed for a couple of days - martin aston
Yes, Edinburgh childhood until Uni, then Aberdeen before moving to England in my late twenties. Seems from this thread we have the makings of a Caledonian Society right here.
 Forth Road Bridge closed for a couple of days - Runfer D'Hills
As tenuous coincidences go, this is fairly out there, but the father of one of my childhood friends and neighbours in Edinburgh had a burgundy coloured DB6. I know you're not him by the simple and sad expedient of knowing the chap in question is no longer with us, but I suppose I wonder if you ever remember seeing the car? There weren't too many Aston Martins around in Edinburgh back then!
 Forth Road Bridge closed for a couple of days - martin aston
Sorry no. However my uncle is a Edinburgh based car buff (used to race for Chatham Honda for example) and I will ask him if it rings any bells when I am up at Christmas. My motoring related Edinburgh memories are watching racing at Ingliston and the joys of driving a rear engined Renault on wet cobbles.
 Forth Road Bridge closed for a couple of days - Armel Coussine
Yes, when my parents lived near Dunfermline and I lived in London I used the ferry, and also remember the road bridge being built. Made a great difference in journey time but it was a loss somehow.
 Forth Road Bridge closed for a couple of days - Runfer D'Hills
>> Yes, when my parents lived near Dunfermline...

Rosyth?
 Forth Road Bridge closed for a couple of days - VxFan
Looks like help is on its way and will be sorted sooner than first thought.

s-media-cache-ak0.pinimg.com/736x/90/df/84/90df84607451f5b45b2df89b8bb0af49.jpg
 Forth Road Bridge closed for a couple of days - Armel Coussine
Place called Crombie, sort of admiralty barrack disguised as a village, with my dad's posh but bleak house and one other, I seem to remember Humph.

Used to get plastered in the police canteen I remember, somewhat less distinctly though. The fuzz seemed indulgent.
 Forth Road Bridge closed for a couple of days - Falkirk Bairn
>>Place called Crombie, sort of admiralty barrack disguised as a village

Last time I passed Crombie I noticed the "Social Club" was no more.

It is not that long ago that Social Clubs, Railway Club, BP Club, ICI Club, Naval Club, British Legion etc all seem to be closing their doors - around my part of the woods at any rate. Always a reasonable pint @ a bargain price.
 Forth Road Bridge closed for a couple of days - Armel Coussine
>> Last time I passed Crombie I noticed the "Social Club" was no more.

Sorry to hear that. But all things pass.

We lived in Crombie, grace and favour gaff sort of. You're right: Rosyth was a focus of my old man's attention. And other places in the Forth estuary whose names I forget.

I was irresposible at the time and pretty stoned. Fitted in fairly well with the local matelots though, slightly to my surprise. Very vaguely remember an uproarious evening when my Notting Hill friend Beckett came to stay for the weekend. He loved my mother's spaghetti sauce.
 Forth Road Bridge closed for a couple of days - Armel Coussine
>> Very vaguely remember an uproarious evening when my Notting Hill friend Beckett came to stay for the weekend.

In the police canteen of course, with a mixed clientele of sailors, admiralty fuzz and us.
 Forth Road Bridge closed for a couple of days - Zero

>> It is not that long ago that Social Clubs, Railway Club, BP Club, ICI Club,
>> Naval Club, British Legion etc all seem to be closing their doors -

Dirty, unkempt smelly scruffy places, Always full of old men whining about the good old days, how bad their employer is, the women sitting around on sagging sofas with holes in. Badly kept beer, warm rola cola (non of this proper branded stuff - no ice of course) The food is crap, The snooker table has a tilt, the cloth is grey with age and the cushions have no bounce,

Hateful places.


They dont even have the only good bit, the old style female pub singer, any more.
 Forth Road Bridge closed for a couple of days - Armel Coussine
>> Dirty, unkempt smelly scruffy places, Always full of old men whining about the good old days,

>> Hateful places.

The Crombie police canteen wasn't like that. No old men and no non-military women (if any at all). Nor did I notice anything wrong with the beer. I was even less of a connoisseur then than I am now, but the coppers and matelots seemed to lap it up.
 Forth Road Bridge closed for a couple of days - Armel Coussine
Can't remember eating anything there, but being called a canteen it must have had food. Sausage egg and chips sort of thing probably. I always liked that sort of thing when on the road, but I could be fed for nothing at home leaving more money for beer.
 Forth Road Bridge closed for a couple of days - tyrednemotional
...have the 'Spoons police been at this thread, or am I suffering from AC syndrome?

 Forth Road Bridge closed for a couple of days - Armel Coussine
>> am I suffering from AC syndrome?

Judging by your handle, I'd say yes.
 Forth Road Bridge closed for a couple of days - Bobby
Any of you who are on twitter, Forth Road Bridge are updating via tweets with the works and some pictures.
Posted a fascinating photo today showing the bridge with no weight on it, and also with 156 tonnes on it (they positioned a row of gritters on the bridge so knew the weight)
The different shape that the supports took on with the weight on the bridge was quite amazing!
 Forth Road Bridge closed for a couple of days - Bobby
Actually, also available on their website
www.forthroadbridge.org/media/1373/load-test.jpg
 Forth Road Bridge closed for a couple of days - Armel Coussine
Wow, that's serious flattening.

Don't see any heavy trucks though. I reckon its just Westpig and a couple of his rotund colleagues stringing those awful striped tapes all over the place and generally giving the citizen the finger so to speak.
 Forth Road Bridge closed for a couple of days - Old Navy
>> Wow, that's serious flattening.
>>

During 100mph winds the centre of the FRB deflects about 20' sideways. There is a photo of it somewhere which I can't find at the moment.
 Forth Road Bridge closed for a couple of days - Lygonos
It'll take one hell of a storm to blow the bridge over.

Traffic on the other hand...

www.youtube.com/watch?v=jbhOUl9ppy4
 Forth Road Bridge closed for a couple of days - Duncan
>> Posted a fascinating photo today showing the bridge with no weight on it, and also
>> with 156 tonnes on it (they positioned a row of gritters on the bridge so
>> knew the weight)
>> The different shape that the supports took on with the weight on the bridge was
>> quite amazing!
>>

Says 518T (tons/tonnes?) on the photo.
 Forth Road Bridge closed for a couple of days - Bobby
sorry my mistook
 Forth Road Bridge closed for a couple of days - Old Navy
>> Says 518T (tons/tonnes?) on the photo.
>>

I think those photos are a single heavy load crossing the bridge some time ago. It is sometimes closed for heavy or wide loads to cross. The photos are taken looking North and if it was recent you would see the North tower of the new bridge to the left of the road bridge.
Last edited by: Old Navy on Thu 31 Dec 15 at 19:20
 Forth Road Bridge closed for a couple of days - Old Navy
Missed the edit -

Also you can't see the reinforcing plates added to the bridge towers some years ago.
 Engineers aim to open Forth Road Bridge by 4 Jan - henry k
www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-scotland-scotland-politics-35096668
 Engineers aim to open Forth Road Bridge by 4 Jan - Avant
Thanks for that - it says that the bridge is closed because "a crack was discovered in a truss under the carriageway."

They should never have made her Environment Secretary.
 Engineers aim to open Forth Road Bridge by 4 Jan - smokie
Reopening tomorrow, no HGVs

www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-scotland-edinburgh-east-fife-35160296
 New bridge update. - Old Navy
The new bridge (Queensferry crossing) is coming along, having been abroad for a couple of weeks and the old bridge being closed on our return we have seen a big change in the month since we last saw it.

www.fifetoday.co.uk/news/local-headlines/video-drone-footage-of-work-on-queensferry-crossing-1-3986957
 New bridge update. - henry k
Forth Road Bridge closure inquiry to begin at Holyrood

www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-scotland-scotland-politics-35354846
 New bridge update. - Zero
>> Forth Road Bridge closure inquiry to begin at Holyrood
>>
>> www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-scotland-scotland-politics-35354846

Enquiry? they will blame it not he English in general and the Tories in particular, and would never have happened under independence.

There just saved them several million quid, bet they are not grateful.
 New bridge update. - Old Navy
Many a true word, Z. The Edinburgh tram inquiry is running at two million quid and increasing.
 New bridge update. - Falkirk Bairn
>>Many a true word, Z. The Edinburgh tram inquiry is running at two million quid and increasing.

The new NHS call handling system is running £50m over the estimate of £78m and we learn today there are no clauses in the contract to enure the system is able to cope with the actual workload. Undoubtedly there needs to be an enquiry - so far the SG have invested in some carpet and a brush!
 New bridge update. - henry k
www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-scotland-edinburgh-east-fife-35492023

Full reopening of Forth Road Bridge delayed by month for HGVs

However, a phased re-introduction of lorries will begin at 23:00.
The trial will allow 600 HGVs to cross northbound between 23:00 and 04:00 each night,
subject to weather conditions.
It was thought the bridge would fully reopen in mid-February
but officials have now said it will be mid-March.
Latest Forum Posts