Hey chaps. Been away with work for a bit, and then flat out when I got back. The usual! :-)
The 130 doesn't have Recaros, although the seats are actually quite similar in design. Just a little squishier than the Recaros, and not quite as supportive. ISTRC you had to buy the 150 to get the "full GTI" spec (including the Recaros and "wood" trim).
With regard to which I'd keep, I'm swapping between the two at the moment and it's interesting to compare. Eliminating differences in age/condition between the two examples, and trying to keep it to actual differences between the two models, the diesel's handling compromise is it's biggest problem. I reckon the GTI would leave it for dead over a twisty road. It handles the bumps better, turns in sharper, grips harder, breaks away more progressively, gets its power down cleaner, and is much less prone to understeer than the diesel. It's interesting too that the ESP light on the diesel blinks fairly frequently (unless you turn it off! :-P), particularly in damp/wet conditions, yet ABS aside, the GTI doesn't have any form of driver aid (being a little older), not even traction control, and doesn't miss either. It has a far better basic setup than the diesel.
Engine wise though, I love that PD diesel. 310NM of torque at 1900 RPM in a 1200-ish kilo car makes for ridiculously effortless progress. There's an uphill slip road onto a NSL dual carriageway near work which you enter in 2nd off a tight roundabout, so no run-up is possible. The diesel will be at 60-65 at the top of that slip road without the throttle touching the floor, or the rev counter passing 3000 RPM at any point, and you get a lovely squeeze in the back as it does so. It feels unstoppable. That said, when I get back in the petrol, it seems almost electric motor quiet in comparison, and has none of the little vibes through the pedals and steering wheel rim that you get in the diesel. It's also nice when you're in the mood to be able to extend the engine, and enjoy the sustained pull of a petrol engine.
It's when you factor costs into it that the diesel's case becomes incredibly strong. Low VED, low depreciation, lower insurance, and a real world 15-20 mpg advantage. For similar on road performance. I'd probably keep the diesel. But I like both! :-)
Last edited by: DP on Tue 15 Jun 10 at 15:53
|